Absolutely tired of hearing people lobby for Pat Tillman to be inducted into the Pro Football Hall of Fame. I appreciate i’m not going to make myself lots of friends here today but I simply can’t quite get why Americans always seem to mix things up whenever ‘US troops’ are involed in any debate, conversation, you name it. Pat Tillman was a marginally good football player who decided to prematurely end his professionnal football career to go in the Army and serve his country after the notorious events of 9/11. This is an act of bravoure, and he got the US Army medals and honours to recognize his military heroism during the war. This is where it should end. But apparently, people think he is also deserving for the Hall of Fame, the ‘Pro Football Hall of Fame” that is. I’m asking, why is that? I think if we go on inducting Pat Tillman for his ‘off the field heroics”, then we ought to immediately remove the likes of OJ Simpson and Lawrence Taylor for their ‘off the field crimes”. HOF voters are told to solely focus over the ‘on the field’ actions of the former players and I would agree that this is how things should be done in Canton, most people do agree as well. Why then in the case of Tillman do people want to make an exception and induct a player who had very moderate success on a team (the Cardinals), the laughingstock of the league at that time. It just doesn’t make any sense at all to mix things up, for the sake of patriotism only. I think we should leave Tillman’s story to what it is: a professoinal athlete who decided to leave the sport, join the forces and serve his country abroad. Already an amazing story in itself.



ESPN Football
Seb 1:54 am on July 5, 2011 Permalink
The Pro Football Hall of Fame’s mission statement is “to honor individuals who have made outstanding contributions to professional football”. Most of them naturally come on the field, from players themselves. But not always. The 2011 Hall of Fame class includes Ed Sabol, founder of NFL Films, whose impact on the development and reach of NFL football is undisputed. So clearly, off-field contribution – to professional football – does matter.
What about non-football-related contributions? As it stands today, there is no room for such praise in the Hall of Fame. Except… if they promote the positive values of the sport, as the mission statement also indicates. And while I agree Patrick Tillman’s football production does not belong in Canton, his sacrificing his NFL career (and ultimately his life) to serve his country echoes one of the fundamental values in football: putting the collective interest ahead of one’s own.
Is that to say he deserves a bronze bust? I don’t think so, but his story, along with several others (see Joe Delaney’s here: http://bit.ly/lSWsDa), could still find a valuable place in the Hall and inspire generations to come without taking anything away from the exceptional athletes enshrined.
Guillaume 6:50 am on July 6, 2011 Permalink
i think your first sentence, the HOF’s mission statement: “to honour individuals who have made outstanding contributions to PROFESSIONNAL FOOTBALL” sums it up: Sabol made an outstanding contribution to Pro Football with NFL Films. I date anyone to say he didn’t. As for today’s topic, Pat Tillman, he never ‘outstandingly’ contributed to Pro Football either on or off the field. Hopefully this should settle the issue we have here. Patt Tillman in the Pro Football Hall of Fame is a BIG NO.
Seb 11:59 pm on July 6, 2011 Permalink
“Date anyone”? No you won’t… ;)
Guillaume 4:48 am on July 7, 2011 Permalink
HA!
Bennie 8:33 am on December 14, 2011 Permalink
As I sit here and read this blog I cant help but ponder how an individual doesnt think Pat Tillman is a Hall of Famer. As well, I cant seem to figure out how another human being doesnt see his contributions to the game. Then, I found some clarity in the matter when I remembered that there are two different people in this world: Smart people and Idiots. The smart person in this matter sees Pat Tillman as a Hall of Famer, no brainer. The idiot inadvertantly allows their personal shortcomings to interfere with their better judgement. It would be pointless for the smart person to state any type of further case because the idiot will never get it no matter how strong the points are.Therefore, the smart person recognizes this and lays the issue to rest knowing that it takes the idiots of the world for the smart people to distinguish themselves.
Guillaume 10:57 am on December 14, 2011 Permalink
we love you Bennie. We love you because you are so smart and it helps idiots like me get better :-). Oh, and by the way, you forgot to end your rant with: “God Bless America” ! “Oooooh, sayyyy can’t you see by the dawn’s early light”.
Guillaume 10:59 am on December 14, 2011 Permalink
oups, and i forgot to say: almost 8 years after his death, Pat is still NOT in the Hall of Fame as a matter of fact. I guess there are A LOT of idiots sitting amongst the Pro Football Hall of Fame board. These 40 idiots sitting at the discussion table, and me. 41 vs. one smart guy = YOU ARE OVERWHELMED BENNY! goodbye, and please shut the door after you leave.